Which ERP software suits your manufacturing company the best?

A production schedule that has to be adjusted again and again. Parts that don’t arrive on time. Or work orders where it only becomes clear afterwards what they actually cost. These are familiar problems for many manufacturers, especially as the organisation grows and processes become more complex.
At some point, the question comes up: do we need different software?
There are various solutions available, from material planning software to complete ERP systems. What fits best depends on your production process and the problems you want to solve.
That’s why at Cadran we always start by looking at how a company works. How does a production order move through the organisation? What information do employees need? And what happens when a customer wants to change something midway?
In this article, we discuss seven questions that will help you choose software for your manufacturing company.
Which software do you need to manage your production?
When you start looking for manufacturing software, you quickly come across a range of terms. Three of them are MRP, MES and ERP.
Three types of manufacturing software
What MRP, MES and ERP do for your production.
| System | What does it do? |
|---|---|
| MRP Material Requirements Planning | Helps you determine which materials you need, how many and when they need to be available. |
| MES Manufacturing Execution System | Supports the execution and recording of work on the shop floor. |
| ERP Enterprise Resource Planning | Connects processes such as production, purchasing, inventory management, sales and finance in one system. |
MRP Material Requirements Planning
MES Manufacturing Execution System
ERP Enterprise Resource Planning
These solutions can exist side by side. MRP functionality, for example, is often part of an ERP system, and a specialised MES can exchange data with ERP.
So a completely new ERP system isn’t always necessary. If your main problems lie in material planning, a targeted solution may be enough. But do your departments work with separate systems, with employees constantly re-entering data? Then an integrated ERP system may be the better choice.
Seven questions to help you choose manufacturing software
What do you want to improve with new software?
Before you start comparing software, it’s wise to take a look at how you work today. Where do you run into problems?
Perhaps it takes a lot of time to create a reliable production schedule. Or you only discover during production that certain parts aren’t in stock. It could also be that production itself runs smoothly, but nobody knows exactly what an order ended up costing.
These are different problems, and they don’t automatically call for the same solution.
So decide which processes you want to improve and what that should deliver. That way, you avoid spending a lot of time comparing features you will hardly ever use.
What does your production process look like?
A company that makes large volumes of standard products has different software requirements than an organisation that mainly produces to customer order.
The way your production is organised also makes a difference. Do you carry out all the work yourself? Or do you outsource parts and operations to other companies?
With customer-specific production, for example, it’s important to look at how the software handles changes. Say a customer requests a change after production preparation has already started. Does the schedule adjust accordingly, and can you see which materials are no longer needed?

IN PRACTICE
Electric wheelchair manufacturer Dietz implements NetSuite ERP
“NetSuite is a system that lets you face the future, gives you insight and still makes you feel you’re not completely dependent on third parties.”
Dick van de Beek — Director, Dietz Power
How the switch went
DIETZ Power in Helmond manufactures electric wheelchairs that can be customised to the user down to the smallest detail. The company chose Oracle NetSuite to support its business processes, with Cadran as its implementation partner.
It’s a good example of how a cloud-based ERP system can also be used for customer-specific production.
How do you manage bills of materials and material availability?
A production schedule can be as good as you like, but without the right materials you won’t get far.
For companies that work with bills of materials (BOMs), it’s important that the software shows which components are needed and when they need to be available.
When comparing systems, look at points such as these:
- Can you manage multi-level bills of materials?
- Can you record different versions of a bill of materials?
- Can the system automatically calculate which materials are needed?
- What happens when a supplier delivers later than planned?
That last point in particular can have major consequences. If a single component is missing, you want to be able to quickly identify which production orders will be delayed as a result.
What happens when the production schedule changes?
A rush order that comes in unexpectedly, a machine that suddenly breaks down or a supplier who doesn’t deliver on time. However carefully you plan, changes are almost impossible to avoid.
The question is how well your software deals with them.
A planner needs to be able to see what capacity is available, which work orders are in progress and where problems could arise. At the same time, employees on the shop floor need to know what an adjusted schedule means for their work.

IN PRACTICE
User-friendly production planning at IKO Metals
“The key users say that the system we have now works much better than the old custom solution. We also have much more control over our processes.”
Michel Petitjean — CEO, IKO Group
How Cadran approached it
At IKO Metals, the user-friendliness of production planning was a key point of attention. During the JD Edwards implementation, Cadran developed a visual planning board that lets employees view the schedule for the next sixteen weeks.
Cadran also developed a Workorder Cockpit. To do this, Cadran worked with the key users to find out what information they needed and which tasks they carried out every day. Based on that, the process was simplified, with fewer steps for employees.
This example shows that the right software isn’t just about functionality. Employees also need to be able to work with it comfortably and efficiently.
How important are quality and traceability?
How much information do you need to be able to retrieve about a manufactured item?
For some companies, it’s enough to record which materials were used and how many products were made. Other organisations need to record in much more detail how a product came about.
Think of serial numbers, batch registration, quality checks and engineering changes.
You may need to be able to trace exactly which components went into a particular product. Or to demonstrate which quality checks were carried out during production.
Map out these requirements before you choose software. If you discover later that important data can’t be recorded properly, you may have to rethink how your system is set up.
What happens after a product has been delivered?
Not every manufacturer’s process ends when a product leaves the building. Companies that supply machines or installations, for example, often remain involved after delivery. They provide maintenance, supply spare parts or carry out repairs.
In that case, it’s wise to look beyond a system’s production features alone.
Can a service engineer see which parts are in a machine and what work has been done on it before? And are the parts used added to the invoice automatically? If service is an important part of your business, the software also needs to support that work properly.
How does the software work with your existing systems?
Choosing a new ERP system doesn’t automatically mean you have to replace all your other software.
Many manufacturers use CAD software for engineering, for example, a Warehouse Management System (WMS) for warehouse processes or specialist applications for certain production steps. So decide in advance which systems you want to keep and what information needs to be exchanged between them.
An example: an engineer changes a technical design. That change then needs to reach the people responsible for bills of materials, purchasing and production. How is that handled?
Also think about how those integrations are managed. If data isn’t transferred correctly, it needs to be clear where things go wrong and who is responsible for fixing it.
When do you choose NetSuite or JD Edwards?
If it turns out that an integrated ERP system is the best fit for your organisation, Oracle NetSuite and Oracle JD Edwards are two possible solutions.
Oracle NetSuite
A cloud-based ERP system that supports production, inventory management, order processing and finance. It can be a good fit for growing manufacturers that want to manage their processes from a single environment.
Oracle JD Edwards
Offers extensive capabilities for production, supply chain, planning and financial management. It is used by mid-sized and larger manufacturers with complex processes, multiple locations or extensive integration needs, among others.
Which system fits best doesn’t just depend on the size of your company. Your existing IT landscape, the functionality you need, your international activities and the way you work also play a role.
Cadran has experience with both ERP systems. That means we can work with you to determine which solution matches your production processes and the requirements you have for the software.
Our advice: test the software with a real production order
A software demo usually gives you a good picture of the available features. But how do you know whether the system will also work for the situations that arise in your company? Our advice is to use a real production order as your starting point.
Choose an order, for example, that requires several components, involves multiple departments working together and has part of its production outsourced.
Then ask to see what happens when an important component arrives later than planned, or when a customer requests a change midway.
Can the planner immediately see the consequences? Does the buyer have the right information? And is it clear to the production department what needs to happen?
Testing a real-life scenario like this gives you a much better picture of how the software fits your day-to-day work. That often says more than a demonstration in which everything goes according to plan.

Bart Dix
Managing Partner
Need help choosing ERP software for your manufacturing company?
Facing the choice of a new ERP system? Then it’s wise to first take a close look at your current production processes and the bottlenecks you want to tackle. We’d be happy to explore with you what NetSuite and JD Edwards can do for your organisation.
